| Year | NIT Champion | Next season |
| 2008 | ||
| 2007 | West Virginia | (7) seed, sweet 16 |
| 2006 | South Carolina | No NCAA tournament |
| 2005 | South Carolina | No NCAA tournament |
| 2004 | Michigan | No NCAA tournament |
| 2003 | St John's | No NCAA tournament |
| 2002 | Memphis | (7) seed, first round loss |
| 2001 | Tulsa | (12) seed, round of 32 |
| 2000 | Wake | (7) seed, first round loss |
| 1999 | Cal | No NCAA tournament |
| 1998 | Minnesota | (7) seed, first round loss |
| 1997 | Michigan | (3) seed, round of 32 |
| 1996 | Nebraska | No NCAA tournament |
| 1995 | VaTech | (9) seed, round of 32 |
| 1994 | Villanova | (3) seed, first round loss |
| 1993 | Minnesota | (6) seed, round of 32 |
| 1992 | UVa | (6) seed, sweet 16 |
| 1991 | Stanford | (12) seed, first round loss |
| 1990 | Vandy | (9) seed, first round loss |
| 1989 | St. John's | (6) seed, round of 32 |
| 1988 | UConn | No NCAA tournament |
| 1987 | Southern Mississippi | No NCAA tournament |